I have reordered this product for a few years now. It works and it seems to be the only that doesn’t give me an orange tinge. I haven’t even been using a toning shampoo (which I should, but just saying). Just to note my hair does lighten easily in the sun and is naturally dark dirty blonde. This product helps me add highlights and blend the greys since I’m in my early 40’s and don’t want to dye my hair yet. I use it about two-three times a month. Thanks for this product!